Two girls charged in Toronto ‘swarming’ are returned to custody

Two women charged in a deadly swarming assault on a homeless man downtown are again in custody, the Star has realized.

As a result of there was no police details about what brought about their return to custody, nor was the details about their subsequent court docket appearances publicized — as is typical with most youth issues in Ontario — members of the media weren’t current to study particular particulars on why the 2 women had been individually taken again into custody final month.

Late final yr, eight women had been charged within the loss of life of Toronto homeless man Kenneth Lee in what police described as a “swarming” assault outdoors Union Station. All however one of many teenagers had been later launched on bail following a sequence of prolonged court docket hearings.

The Star has been overlaying the unprecedented case carefully during the last six months and on Tuesday raised a difficulty of entry to primary info in a case of public curiosity. On Thursday, Ontario Court docket Justice Maria Sirivar allowed restricted particulars concerning the women’ return to custody to be launched to a reporter.

In line with the data offered, one of many women was charged on Might 4 with two counts of failing to adjust to circumstances of her April 26 launch on bail. No particulars had been offered about what circumstances the lady allegedly breached, apart from that neither depend pertains to violence.

The second lady was introduced again into custody on Might 17 — three weeks after she was granted bail, additionally on April 26 — not as a result of she is alleged to have dedicated any new offence however as a result of one of many individuals who agreed to be answerable for her revoked that standing. No different particulars had been offered.

Each women had been ordered below strict home arrest that required them to be below fixed supervision of the individuals who bailed them out — labelled a “accountable individual” — and to to not go away house except with a type of adults. They had been additionally barred from having a cellphone or utilizing social media in addition to possessing any weapons.

A accountable individual is akin to a surety for younger individuals below the Youth Prison Justice Act, however comes with extra critical penalties if the younger individual fails to comply with their circumstances, together with the opportunity of jail time for the grownup. The regulation permits for somebody who beforehand promised to be a accountable individual to ask the court docket to take away the younger individual from their care at any time if they’re now not keen or capable of perform that position.

The identities of each younger persons are protected by the identical act, which was created, partially, to acknowledge a must rehabilitate younger individuals concerned within the justice system.

Each women had been initially denied bail however had been launched by Justice Sirivar in April after their legal professionals raised issues about “unacceptable” circumstances, together with being flown through a constitution flight to a facility in Kenora, Ont.

As of Thursday, they remained in custody at a youth facility together with a 3rd lady — the one teen among the many eight who has been in custody since Lee’s loss of life. That lady is at present within the course of of getting an earlier determination to disclaim her bail reviewed.

In line with police accounts, the eight women — on the time, aged 13, 13, 13, 14, 14, 14, 16 and 16 — allegedly swarmed and attacked Lee, 59, close to a short lived homeless shelter close to York Road and College Avenue. All eight are charged with second-degree homicide.

The allegations haven’t been examined in court docket. The proof heard at their bail hearings is topic to a publication ban.

The opposite 5 women had been beforehand launched on bail and are below home arrest.

A preliminary listening to within the case is scheduled to start in April 2024.

SHARE: