In Could 2022, the European Fee proposed the European Well being Information Area (EHDS) in an try to enhance the methods by which folks’s delicate medical knowledge is made obtainable for numerous sorts of makes use of.
That features the power for hospitals and physicians to share details about present sufferers with skilled colleagues overseas. For instance, it is purported to make it simpler for a GP in Sweden to obtain a digital copy of their Romanian affected person’s CT scan outcomes from the radiologist in Romania to be able to proceed therapy.
The EHDS additionally proposes to legally compel hospitals or physicians at hand out your medical data to a newly created authorities company, which in flip, can permit entry to anybody who claims a analysis curiosity. That features not solely teachers but additionally pharmaceutical firms, wellness app startups and even knowledge harvesting Massive Tech companies like Google and Fb.
Your medical data embrace particulars of bodily, psychological and sexual well being, drug and alcohol historical past, and any household and work-related issues that you just thought you’d disclosed in confidence to your doctor solely. What’s worse is that the knowledge in medical data is sort of not possible to successfully anonymise, that means it is comparatively simply identifiable as yours.
That’s the reason 75 % of Europeans stated in a current Ipsos ballot that they’re solely keen to grant researchers entry to their medical data if they’ve been requested for his or her specific consent, and that is what the EHDS ought to require.
Massive Tech is on the transfer
With out such a consent requirement, Google, for example, might acquire entry to the main points of your most cancers therapy or the outcomes of your final psychotherapy session to coach its new AI for some well-being app. And the result of which may feed into the corporate’s promoting enterprise.
If you happen to do not like that, you’re in unhealthy luck: the EHDS doesn’t foresee sufferers being requested for his or her permission; it doesn’t even embrace a proper to object to this sort of extreme knowledge sharing.
Your medical data comprise details about all elements of your life. From the second you had been born, via childhood, puberty, and each sick go away, psychological problem, and different well being points you ever had. You ought to be the one in command of it.
Greater than a dozen organisations representing sufferers, medical professionals, individuals with disabilities, client and digital rights organisations, in addition to staff and commerce unions have written to members of the EU Parliament, urging them to introduce the consent requirement within the well being knowledge proposal. That is essential for safeguarding sufferers’ rights and guaranteeing that they’ve management over the usage of their personal medical data.
Bye bye Hippocratic oath
The EHDS would make physicians and different medical professionals complicit within the pressured commercialisation and monetisation of each facet of your well being with out ever asking on your consent. It will destroy the Hippocratic oath of confidentiality by which each medical skilled is meant to be certain.
The worldwide tech business is simply ready for the chance to get their palms on Europeans’ medical knowledge. Apple already has an in depth “digital well being” supply and, in 2020, Google paid over $2bn [€1.82bn] to amass well being machine maker Fitbit in an try and enter the well being knowledge market.
Google’s acquisition of Fitbit demonstrates the massive financial worth well being knowledge has, even to firms who don’t contribute to public curiosity medical analysis, and why it ought to by no means be shared with third events with out your consent.
Not forgetting governments and cyber-criminals
Your medical data should not solely of curiosity to companies. As soon as saved in central, state-run knowledge centres because the EHDS proposes, they might simply as properly be misused by your personal authorities.
In January 2023, Polish police raided a non-public gynaecologist workplace within the metropolis of Szczecin. The prosecutor claimed that “legal acts” had been carried out within the type of medical abortions requested by sufferers. Poland has a de facto ban on abortion. Through the raid, medical data relationship again so far as 1996 had been confiscated.
Simply think about how straightforward it could be for the Polish authorities to persecute any girl whose medical data comprise the slightest indication that she may think about in search of an abortion, if all people’s medical knowledge was held in a central database run by that very same authorities.
And there may be extra: forcing the medical data of tens of millions of individuals right into a centralised database creates an extremely enticing goal for malicious hackers around the globe.
Join EUobserver’s day by day publication
All of the tales we publish, despatched at 7.30 AM.
By signing up, you conform to our Phrases of Use and Privateness Coverage.
With this sort of intimate info, widespread criminals can extort ransom from you by threatening to show your medical particulars. Simply final yr, a legal ransomware gang broke into the medical database of a healthcare methods supplier within the US and began publishing nude photos of feminine breast most cancers sufferers on the web after the supplier refused to pay the ransom.
Medical analysis is extremely necessary and infrequently depends on entry to such knowledge to develop new medicine and advance our understanding of the human physique. However whoever needs to do this analysis should at all times ask on your permission to make use of your knowledge first. Ideally, they need to be obliged to launch their analysis outcomes again to the general public, in order that it may be of most widespread worth to us all.
EU lawmakers subsequently should amend the EHDS in that sense, in order that we will proceed to entrust our physicians with essentially the most intimate particulars of our bodily, psychological and sexual well being.
